In this blog we will post After Action Reports of our games played by Vassal (and Cyberboard). These are our Alberto Pomar - Alberto Molina - Jordi "Dolent" Alberto Reports (AAARs)
Saturday, September 7, 2013
Killing ground impressions:
Friday, July 12, 2013
TURN 2 (GERMAN PHASE)
Saturday, July 6, 2013
THE KILLING GROUND TURN 2 (7th-July-1944)
- 2- ARMY SUPPORT AND REPLACEMENT: No new army is activated this turn. Rolling how many sp are received this turn, it depends on the weather and the sea condition. USA dr=6-1 (USA support drm for 7-july)+1 Cherbourg.+1 daily=7 it is 7sp’s for 1st USA army. So now at the reserve there are 13 sp’s. British dr=4 +1=5 (daily no table drm for brits), it means 6 sp’s, now Brit reserve=6+10=16
-
USA 358 and 357 from (90div), 26 (1st div). Brit 158 (53div)Now banked: Usa=2, Brit=1, Can=1 RE pointsB Reinforcements are added this step, this turn: American 9th inf div at Cherbourg+899TD batallion. 2nd div of 2 can corp brit depot and two german regiments at 12 area.3.- MOVEMENT PHASENo major changes in american 8th corp front area. (west of Cotentin Pennisula)In american 7th corp area we can see the approach of 9th división just disembarched at Cherbourg (it came so fast due to the trucks)If with the americans I can save enough sp’s to get an operation for next turn it will be launched with 7th corp, as it has two elite full strength divisions (A3 counters) 9th div and 30th div. 7th corp Hq is at Carentan.In next picture we see american 5th and 19th corps area. German 2P div is covering St. Lo. We see too the boundery line between american and british sectors.British movement phase: Two regiments from 53div (12th corp) retreats from front to rest and 3 can div uses start move to reach 2can HQ, no other major changes in british front area 7th of july…except for 30th corp operation…49 and 50 div attack elements of Panzer Lehr. In reserve 11 armored and Guards división. If any of the attacks get a hole, tanks in reserve will enter to get another attack.N4236 attack:Combat secuence:1- Attacker declares suppported attack so 30 corp pays 1 sp from the corp reserve (so 6-1 =5 sp’s).2- Brit now declares one air support and support from the 5 AGRA regiment.3- German can’t declare artillery support as they are far away from 47corps artillery.4- Chits drawn for every regiment (new in combat)231 reg (A3=11);151 inf (A2=10) both from 50 inf division. 131 mech. Inf (A2=9)+2 cadre. Total=32. German KG=9(already tested)+tank batallion=10.5- Brit units=32, German=106- 32/10 is a 3vs1 attack on bocage row. But now before rolling dice the ratio may change due to:a. Divisional integrity: one column right as all 50th div is adjacent (4vs1)b. Air support, an air chit is drawn (available air points now is 4) 2 shifts in favor of attacker (1 less due to bogage terrain hex.) (5vs1)c. British artillery support, rolling in 12 column of the table (+2 for bocage -1 for hilltop) dr=5 is 2 col shift (7vs1).d. No combined arm bonus here as defender has infantry and armore. ASV attackers have one White dot, defenders 3 (black+White) so defender gets a one shift left (6vs1)f. Infantry defending in bocage gets a 1 col shift (5vs1)Rolling two dice in 5vs1 “bocage”= 7. 1<1/1 It means 1 casualty and one hex retreat for attacker and one step loose for the defender.N4238 attack:Combat secuence:1- Attacker declares suppported attack so 30 corp pays 1 sp from the corp reserve (so 5-1 =4 sp’s).2- British now declares one air support and support from the 55Hv regiment.3- German can’t declare artillery support as they are far away from 47corps artillery.4- Chits drawn for every regiment , giving (new in combat) Brit units=16, German=105- 16/10 is a 2vs1 attack on bocage row. But now before rolling dice the ratio may change due to:a. Divisional integrity: one column right as all 49th div is adjacent (3vs1)b. Air support, an air chit is drawn (available air points now is 4) 2 shifts in favor of attacker (1 less due to bogage terrain hex.) (4vs1)c. British artillery support, rolling in 5 column of the table (+2 TEM) dr=5 is 1 col shift (5vs1).d. No combined arm bonus here as defender has infantry and armore. ASV attackers have three White dots, defenders 2 (black+White) so attackers r gets a one shift left (6vs1)f. Infantry defending in bocage gets a 1 col shift (5vs1)Rolling two dice in 5vs1 “bocage”= 4. D/1>2 It means Disorganized for 3 attackers (2 remaining units +1 stillZoc).Defenders losses 1 step (inf reg.) and retreats two hexes along the road to Villiers-Bocage.American 7th corp attack N3723. Failed attack resulting attackers retreat with one step loss for german 897 inf reg.5.- RESERVE MOVEMENT:Situation after reserve movement in 30th corp operation area. In red retreat after combat phase. 50 inf div retreats after failing the attack against Panzer Lehr elements. 5 miles east, in spite of being “disorg” 49th british div. forced to retreat back 902 panzer grenadieren. Then in reserve move mode 11 armored and Guards armored moved through the gap (blue) in order to try to make the breach bigger (black).Reserve attacks. N4236. Guards armor div attack elements of Panzer Lehr. 901 pz gren. were destroyed Stug III batallion retreats back, and 11 armored division advanced. In N4339, 11 armored div were incredible lucky in a suicidal attack against 19 inf reg supported by panthers and achieved an incredible “retreat result”.6.- Engineering phase Each Ip began last turn is finished now. Each corp Hq may begin again an Ip for free, in brit sector corps 8th and 12th. In amercian area all corps did it.7 Disorganization/Regroup phase. Regroup allied units return to normal, and german “disorg” units passes to “regroup”.End of allied phase. Soon german phase of turn 7th of july 1944
Sunday, June 30, 2013
LEARNING THE KILLING GROUND
Thursday, June 13, 2013
N44, 14th June
Utah.
Omaha
Caen
Now, German had the full 12 SS Div into reserve, being able to penetrate deep into British lines to hit the already heavily decimated 50 inf Div.
Conclusion:
For the first game of N44 we had made a few mistakes in the rules that could outcome the final result.
First of all, we completely forgot about Allied IPs that could be useful for British. Also we have missed that replacements in storm turns can be either Brits or Canadians. We had assigned to British. A mistake.
More subtle mistakes were made when applying ZOC Bonds, DCBs or applying retreat. When possible we have corrected the errors.
Strategically, British did not realize his delicate position until that it was too late. He needed to be more cautious.
German had also many errors, some of the quite evident.
American, as usual, played perfectly :-))
A great first game. We have now a good understanding of the rules and we are planning to play again the campaign.
We truly believe that this is an excellent game that deserves to play with. We are anxiously waiting to jump into Ardennes 44. Our only regret is that N44 is now out of stock as well as Ukraine 43 that, under a similar system, we would like to try.
Our deepest thanks for this wonderful game to Mark Simonitch and the people at GMT.
Monday, June 10, 2013
N44, 13th June
Again Overcast-2 at Normandy.
Utah Beach:
Omaha Beach:
CW Beaches:
Map:
Thursday, May 30, 2013
N44, 12th June
A sunny day in Normandy, Weather is clear 6, so plenty of air and naval support for the Allies.
In turn, the Germans get useful reinforcements with the arrival of the 17th Pz SS Div and elements of the 3FJ Div. The good weather allow a full control of the skies for the Allies and the mechanized German units have its movement allowance reduced by two. In fact this means that German will not be able to deploy 17th Pz SS this turn.
German has made a cautious turn, with no attacks to avoid the column shift of the Jabos and trying to reinforce his positions. I realize that we have been playing the IP rule in a wrong way forcing German to spend IP points for beginning the building and for finishing, thus reducing his capability for trenches almost to a half. We will modify our mistake next turn.
Utah Beach:
WWII: BtB, Turn 15, Fall 44
No Orders from the Fuhrer this turn while Stalin has asked his generals to continue with the offensive .
With the time running out and the Allies more and more stronger, Axis begun the turn playing an event for getting one more Victory point.
But in the last action of the turn, Germans surrendered after American First Army entered Berlin.
This is the final map
Step losses this turn:
Ge: 34 steps, It: 3 steps.
Ru: 17 steps, Br: 6 steps.
Losses really reflects the heavy combats in this last turn.
A great game played Alberto Molina (Axis) and Alberto Pomar (Allied) from March 9th, 2013 to May 27th, 2013.
WWII:BtB, Turn 14, Summer 44
More and more voices are claiming in Russia for a total offensive and Stavka gave orders at the beginning of the summer 44 to attack.
German begun cautiously, by reinforcing his Force Pool with Mechanized Corps and preparing replacements.
In turn, Soviet Commanders brought into the battlefield several Shock and Mechanized Armies from the reserve and initiated the expected offensive in the first week of summer.
Map at the end of summer:
A very bloody turn. Losses were
German: 25 steps, IT: 6, Romanian: 4
Russian: 27 steps, US. 4 steps.
VP= +6 (Orel shifted to Allied).
Wednesday, May 29, 2013
N44, 11th June
More than three weeks later, finally i will report on our progress in N44. Probably the only ones reading this journal are the American players but nevertheless, i have the task of completing it and i will do my duty.
Weather: Overcast 2.
Only one day of clear weather and Allied Airplanes can not give support to the land forces.
Utah Beach:
Omaha Beach:
CW Beaches.
In overall a good turn for the Allied. With bad weather, overcast 2, they have made good progress at Utah and Caen.
After writing this report, I believe that we have made some mistakes in the rules. I will note them and at the end of the game i will try to summarize the easy-to-forget /misunderstood rules.